Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

How is the Captive Insurance Approach to Claims Management Different?

August 26th, 2024

2 min read

By Jerrett Phinney

Captive insurance claims management hero image
How is the Captive Insurance Approach to Claims Management Different?
4:52

Many insurance agents struggle with a fundamental issue: they are not well-versed in the complexities of captive insurance. As a result, there’s a reluctance to talk about the captive model with their clients, leaving a gap in understanding other insurance possibilities. 

This article will give you a clear understanding of how claims management under a captive insurance model differs from traditional insurers. You will see how it puts more control in your hands, offers customized solutions, and aligns closely with your clients’ business goals. 

Understanding Traditional Insurance Claims Management

In traditional insurance, the claims process can be frustrating for businesses. It’s typically marked by standard procedures, limited policyholder involvement, and the possibility of future premium increases based on past claims. 

  • Standardized Claims Handling: Traditional insurers follow a one-size-fits-all approach to managing claims. While this is consistent, it often lacks the flexibility to address the needs of an individual business. This can leave businesses feeling sidelined, leaving little room to negotiate or influence outcomes. 
  • Limited Policyholder Involvement: Once a claim is filed, the insurer’s adjuster takes over. The business owner, who knows their operations best (you would assume), has minimal say in the process. This disconnect can result in decisions that don’t fully align with the business’s priorities or long-term goals. 
  • Impact of Losses on Future Premiums: Frequent claims or a significant loss can lead to higher premiums at renewal. This is largely out of the policyholder’s control and can feel like a penalty for using the coverage they paid for.

How Captive Insurance Takes a Different Approach

Captive insurance offers a model that is more aligned with the needs of businesses with low claims and more focused on safety.

  • Customized Claims Handling: In a captive insurance model, claims management is specifically designed to meet the needs of the captive owner(s). This means the process is flexible, allowing faster responses and more personalized service. Because the insured business also owns the insurance company, there is a vested interest in ensuring that claims are handled efficiently and fairly. 
  • Control Over Settlements: A significant benefit of captive insurance is the control it gives the insured over claim settlements. The adjuster works directly for the captive owner, making settlements in the best interest of the business. This allows for more nuanced negotiations and settlements that better align with the business’s financial and operational goals.
  • Incentives for Loss Control: Captive insurance encourages better risk management. The business owners or captive members benefit directly from fewer and less severe claims, which can lead to increased profitability and financial stability. This creates a proactive approach to loss control, where the focus is on preventing claims rather than just managing them.

  • Insight from Claims Data: A captive provides detailed claims data, which can be analyzed to identify trends and areas for improvement. This data-driven approach allows businesses to enhance their risk management strategies, potentially lowering future claims. 

If you’re wondering how your clients would perform with a captive insurer, take the captive assessment tool to get those results. 

The Broader Implications of Claims Management in Captives

Traditional insurance often leaves businesses feeling powerless and reactive. While captive insurance is not for everyone, it allows business owners to have more control and proactive management.

With captive insurance, businesses not only gain control over the claims process but also influence insurance strategy with their broader financial goals. This approach can lead to more stable insurance costs and a better overall risk management strategy.

Are Captives Right for Your Best Clients?

You’ve learned that captive insurance can provide businesses with better flexibility and control. Captives allow business owners to influence the claims process to better align with their needs. It also encourages proactive risk management, which can lead to fewer claims and enhanced financial stability over time. 

With all this said, captive insurance is not for every business. That’s why you need to read our article about the financial advantages and disadvantages of captive insurance. Weigh the financial pros and cons before you and your best clients shift toward a captive insurance model. 

If you have additional questions or would like to schedule a consultation, contact Captive Coalition to speak with one of our insurance advisors.