As an insurance agent, you’re likely familiar with the frustration your best clients feel during renewal season—premiums spike even when they have few or no claims. Yet, many agents hesitate to discuss captive insurance with their clients due to a lack of understanding or experience with captives.
That’s where Captive Coalition comes in. We specialize in educating agents like you on captive insurance so you can confidently guide your clients toward solutions that fit their needs.
This article will help you better understand captive insurance and determine if it’s a good option for your best clients. With this knowledge, you can introduce this solution in your client conversations with confidence.
What is Captive Insurance?
Captive insurance is a self-insurance strategy where a business forms its own insurance company—or joins a group captive—to cover its risks. Unlike traditional insurance, where premiums are paid to a third-party insurer who controls the rates and profits, captive insurance allows businesses to manage their risk and retain underwriting profits. This model can provide significant benefits for clients, especially those with good claims records, offering more control and potentially lowering long-term costs.
Why Captives Offer More Predictability
Traditional insurance markets often increase premiums, even for low-risk businesses with little to no claims history. Captives, on the other hand, offer a more stable and predictable cost structure. They incentivize businesses to improve risk management since better performance directly impacts their insurance costs.
Additionally, captive owners know where every cent of their premium goes and how that money is distributed. This transparency leads to a more controlled and satisfying insurance experience.
Types of Captive Insurance Structures
There are three primary types of captives:
- Single-Parent Captives: An independent insurance entity formed by a single business to cover its own risks. This structure is more suitable for larger businesses that spend at least $1 million annually on insurance premiums.
- Group Captives: Businesses with similar risk profiles pool resources to create a shared insurance entity. This is a practical option for smaller businesses spending at least $250,000 in premiums, offering the ability to self-insure while sharing risk with others.
- Cell Captives: Multiple businesses share a common insurance framework, each managing its risk within a segregated “cell.” This model offers cost savings and flexibility but may not provide the same level of control as other types of captives.
If you’re curious how your best clients might perform as captive owners, use our captive assessment tool to get those results.
Benefits of Captive Insurance
While captives require more involvement than simply paying a traditional insurance premium, the potential benefits can be substantial:
- Cost Savings: Over time, businesses can reduce their insurance costs, especially if they maintain a low claims record. This leads to increased cash flow through reduced premiums and the retention of underwriting profits.
- Control and Transparency: Captives allow businesses to see exactly where their premiums are going and have a direct say in risk management strategies. This transparency is often a significant draw for businesses frustrated with the traditional market.
- Stability: Captives offer more predictable insurance costs without the surprise price increases that often accompany renewal season.
- Incentives for Risk Management: Since captives directly link risk management performance to financial outcomes, they motivate businesses to improve their safety and risk management programs.
Financial Considerations for Captive Insurance
When it comes to captives, there are key financial commitments to consider:
- Initial Investment: Forming or joining a captive requires upfront costs, including share purchases, collateral (a financial guarantee to ensure claims can be paid), and administrative expenses. For a group captive, this could range from $25,000 to $50,000 for the share, plus additional funds for collateral.
- Ongoing Costs: Premiums paid into a captive cover claims and administrative expenses. These premiums are generally lower over time than traditional insurance, especially for businesses with good claims records.
- Risk Management Fees: Clients may also incur a risk management fee, typically a percentage of their premium, to support the captive’s operations and ensure effective risk management practices.
Challenges and Considerations for Captive Insurance
While captives offer significant benefits, they also come with challenges:
- Regulatory Compliance: Captive insurance companies are subject to regulatory requirements that vary by location. Ensuring compliance is essential to avoid legal and financial complications.
- Risk of Claims: Businesses must be prepared to cover potential claims and have funds set aside for this purpose. In a bad claims year, additional capital may be needed to replenish the captive’s reserves. Even businesses with strong safety and risk management programs will likely face a claim every five or six years.
- Commitment to Risk Management: Success in a captive depends on effective risk management. Businesses that neglect this aspect may face financial penalties or even expulsion from the captive.
Is Captive Insurance Right for Your Small Business Clients?
Captive insurance is now more accessible to small businesses, offering a long-term insurance solution with more control, transparency, and cost efficiency. Understanding the different types of captives, their benefits, and financial considerations can help your clients find a more sustainable insurance option.
Next, read our article about the financial advantages and disadvantages of captive insurers. This will help you and your clients weigh the pros and cons of captives to see if it’s the ideal solution for them.
If you have questions about captive insurers or need a consultation, schedule a call with Captive Coalition to speak with one of our insurance advisors.
Topics:
