The fronting carrier is one of the most important and misunderstood elements of captive insurance. It makes sense, but ironically, the fronting carrier is what backs a captive insurance company. So it isn’t on the forefront of peoples’ minds when it comes to learning about captives.
This article will help you understand what a fronting carrier is, why they’re essential to the captive insurance process, and how they are evaluated.
What is a Fronting Carrier?
A fronting carrier is a licensed insurance company that issues policies on behalf of a captive insurer. While the captive takes on the majority (or all) of the risk through reinsurance agreements, the fronting carrier serves as the “face” of the insurance policy. Their name appears on the insurance certificates. The carrier is also important for regulatory compliance, financial credibility, and contractual requirements.
Why Do Captives Need a Fronting Carrier?
Here are a few reasons captives would need a fronting carrier:
1. Regulatory Compliance
Most states and industries require insurance coverage to be issued by a carrier that meets specific licensing and financial standards. A fronting carrier ensures that the captive’s coverage complies with these rules, especially in areas like workers’ compensation or commercial auto insurance, where regulations are stringent.
2. Financial Credibility
Fronting carriers typically hold strong financial ratings from agencies like A.M. Best. These ratings provide peace of mind to third parties—lenders, vendors, or clients—that the insurance will pay claims if needed. For example, many contracts require an “A-rated” carrier to avoid disputes about the insurer’s financial stability.
3. Custom Solutions for Captives
Since captives often lack their own high financial ratings, the fronting carrier steps in to bridge that gap. This allows the captive to operate while still benefiting from the lower costs and customized coverage that captives provide.
Benefits of a Fronting Carrier
- Recognized Name on Policies: The fronting carrier’s brand appears on the certificate, which fulfills contractual requirements.
- Risk Transfer Oversight: Although captives reinsure the fronting carrier, the carrier provides an extra layer of oversight. The front also makes sure adequate collateral is in place to cover claims.
- Administrative Support: Some fronting carriers offer valuable administrative services, such as issuing endorsements, handling policy documents, and maintaining compliance with state and federal laws.
Challenges of Partnering with a Fronting Carrier
While fronting carriers are an overall benefit to captive insurers, there are challenges to consider:
- Fees and Costs: Fronting carriers charge fees for their services, often as a percentage of the premiums. This fee compensates them for assuming the regulatory and reputational risks associated with issuing the policy.
- Control Limitations: Fronting carriers often impose conditions on the risks the captive can underwrite. This can restrict flexibility in creating coverage for businesses.
- Collaboration Requirements: The fronting carrier may require regular reporting (such as bordereau reports) and additional collateral, especially if claims or exposures grow unexpectedly.
How to Evaluate a Fronting Carrier
When looking at fronting carriers that work with captives, here are some factors to consider:
- Financial Stability: Does the carrier have an “A” rating or better from a respected rating agency?
- Industry Fit: Does the carrier have experience with the specific risks or industries your client operates in?
- Flexibility: Can the carrier accommodate the captive’s structure, or are they rigid in their requirements?
- Reputation: Have they been involved in disputes, regulatory issues, or financial scandals such as the Clear Blue controversy involving fraudulent letters of credit?
A Real-World Example of Fronting Carriers in Action
Imagine a construction company creates a captive to cover its liability risks. The company needs the insurance certificate issued by a fronting carrier to secure project contracts. Without the fronting carrier, lenders or project managers might view their captive’s policy as insufficient. However, the fronting carrier ensures compliance and credibility while the captive reinsures most risks.
Learn More About the Intricacies of Captives
Fronting carriers are significant when it comes to a captive insurer being credible, compliant, and widely accepted. You now better understand why they’re necessary, their benefits, and their challenges. And there’s so much more when it comes to captive insurers.
To further understand the intricacies of captive insurance companies, read our article on how captive insurance companies control losses.
Captive Coalition’s sole purpose is to educate independent agents on captive insurance, including the vital role of fronting carriers. We have tools and resources to help you determine whether captives are the solution for your best clients.
Become a member of Captive Coalition to gain the tools, resources, and expertise needed to succeed.
Topics:
