Skip to main content

«  View All Posts

Top Three Misconceptions About Captive Insurance:

What Independent Agents Need to Know

August 28th, 2024

2 min read

By Jerrett Phinney

Captive Insurance Misconceptions Hero Image
Top Three Misconceptions About Captive Insurance:
3:42

As an independent insurance agent, you’ve likely encountered questions and doubts from your clients about captive insurance. Misconceptions surrounding captives can make it difficult to confidently present this valuable risk management option. When business owners hesitate due to these misunderstandings, they miss out on a powerful tool that could significantly improve their insurance strategy.

At Captive Coalition, we understand the importance of educating independent agents about captives. By understanding and addressing these misconceptions, you can confidently guide your clients toward the best insurance solutions for their needs.

This article will debunk the top misconceptions about captive insurance, helping you have informed conversations with your clients and support their risk management strategies.

Misconception #1: “My Business is Too Small for a Captive Insurance Company”

The Reality: Captive insurance isn’t just for Fortune 500 companies anymore. While captives were once the domain of large corporations, the landscape has changed. Today, businesses spending a minimum of $250,000 annually on combined premiums for workers’ comp, general liability, and auto liability are prime candidates for joining a group captive. For those spending $1 million or more, a single-parent captive could be a perfect fit.

Many business owners who could benefit from a captive simply don’t realize it. As their agent, you can help them see the potential.

Misconception #2: “Captive Insurance Means Losing the Protection of Traditional Insurance”

The Reality: A common fear is that switching to captive insurance means sacrificing protection. In reality, captives can offer coverage that is just as robust—if not more so—than traditional insurance. Captives allow businesses to customize their coverage to meet specific needs, often including fronting policies and reinsurance. These tools ensure that businesses are protected from catastrophic losses, just as they would be with a traditional carrier.

Moving to a captive doesn’t mean giving up protection; it means gaining more control over it.

Misconception #3: “A Major Loss Will Bankrupt My Captive”

The Reality: This concern is understandable, but captives are designed to handle significant claims. One of the key benefits of captives is the focus on loss control and risk management. Premiums paid into a captive are allocated to a loss fund specifically to cover claims. Additionally, reinsurance strategies are in place to ensure that even large claims can be managed without jeopardizing the financial stability of the captive.

Captives are built with resilience in mind, ensuring that they can withstand major losses without financial ruin.

Is Your Best Client a Good Fit for Captives?

Addressing these common misconceptions will better equip you to discuss captive insurance with your clients. This understanding will allow them to make more informed decisions about their insurance and risk management strategies.

Captive insurance isn’t suitable for every business, but for those that fit, the benefits can be substantial. To further explore whether your clients could benefit from a captive, consider reading our article on the financial advantages and disadvantages of captive insurance. This will help you identify which clients could see the greatest value from joining a captive.

If you have questions about captive insurers or want a consultation, schedule a call with Captive Coalition to speak with one of our insurance advisors.