If your clients are frustrated with rising insurance costs and a lack of control over their coverage, they’re not alone. Many businesses find that traditional insurance models don’t align with their risk management efforts or improve their cash flow. Despite these frustrations, captive insurance often goes undiscussed, even by the most knowledgeable agents.
At Captive Coalition, we specialize in both traditional and captive insurance, working closely with independent agents to explore how captives can benefit their clients. We’ve seen firsthand how a well-managed captive can significantly enhance a business’s cash flow.
In this article, we’ll break down how captive insurance works, its impact on cash flow, and what you need to know to determine if it’s the right fit for your clients.
Captive Insurance: The Basics
Before diving into cash flow benefits, it’s essential to understand the basics of captive insurance.
What is Captive Insurance?
Captive insurance is an alternative risk management strategy where businesses, or a group of businesses, create their own insurance company. Unlike traditional insurance, where premiums are paid to a third-party insurer, captives allow businesses to self-insure. This model provides greater control over how premiums are used and can offer financial advantages when managed effectively.
Types of Captives
There are several structures within captive insurance, but here are the three most common:
- Single-Parent Captive: A business creates its own insurance subsidiary to cover its specific risks.
- Group Captive: Unrelated businesses with similar risk profiles pool resources to form a collective insurance entity.
- Cell Captive: Multiple entities share a common insurance structure but operate independently within their own segregated cells, allowing for tailored risk management.
How Captive Insurance Can Improve Your Client’s Cash Flow
Initial Costs and Cash Flow Considerations
When a business first joins a captive, there are upfront costs, including collateral and setup expenses. These initial investments may make the first year more expensive compared to traditional insurance, but they lay the groundwork for long-term financial health.
Collateral Requirements
Collateral acts as a financial guarantee to cover potential claims. While this requirement can increase costs in the first year, business owners often see substantial long-term benefits.
Year Two and Beyond: The Cash Flow Payoff
In the first year, premiums may not decrease significantly. However, as the business demonstrates effective risk management, premiums can decrease by up to 28% by the second or third year, leading to improved cash flow.
When Does Captive Insurance Start Benefitting Your Client’s Cash Flow?
Long-Term Benefits
Captive insurance is a long-term strategy, not a quick fix. For businesses committed to managing risk, the financial rewards can be significant. Cash flow improvements come from several sources:
- Reduced Premiums: As claims remain low, premiums decrease, freeing up capital for other business needs.
- Underwriting Profit: If the business has fewer claims than expected, surplus premiums can be returned as profit.
- Investment Income: Collateral and premiums paid into the captive can be invested, generating additional income.
Short-Term Costs vs. Long-Term Gains
In the short term, businesses may face higher costs due to collateral and the need to enhance risk management practices. However, these costs are offset in the long run by lower premiums, potential profit returns, and investment income.
Potential Risks and Challenges
Impact of High Claims
A high frequency of claims can lead to additional premiums (assessments) that need to be paid to the captive, impacting cash flow in the short term. However, this is similar to traditional insurance, where frequent claims also lead to increased premiums.
Transparency and Control
One of the major advantages of captive insurance is the transparency it offers. Businesses know exactly where their premiums are going and have more control over how those funds are used.
Are Captive Insurers Best for Your Clients?
Captive insurance isn’t for everyone. It requires a commitment to risk management and an understanding that the financial benefits are long-term. However, for clients who are spending a significant amount on traditional insurance and are looking for more control and better cash flow, a captive could be an ideal solution. They can save your best clients a lot of money.
It’s important to weigh the financial advantages and disadvantages of captive insurance. This will help you and your client determine if captives will help their business succeed financially.
If you have questions about captive insurers or want a consultation, schedule a call with Captive Coalition to speak with one of our insurance advisors.
Topics:
